Contraception plays a crucial role in our sexual and reproductive lives, empowering us to decide when and how many children we wish to have. While there are numerous contraceptive options available, this blog post will focus specifically on condoms, withdrawal, and fertility awareness methods. We will explore their benefits, drawbacks, and effectiveness rates to help you make informed decisions.

Choosing contraception is a responsible step towards preventing unintended pregnancies and planning family timing. By gaining a comprehensive understanding of these methods, you and your partner can select the most suitable option for your needs.

So, let’s dive into the three methods we’ll be discussing in this blog: condoms, withdrawal, and fertility awareness.

Condoms

Some Condom Type	Description	Pros	Cons	Efficacy Rate
Latex Condoms	Made from natural rubber latex, this type of condom is the most commonly used.	Effective barrier against STIs and pregnancy, widely available, affordable.	May cause allergic reactions in some people, can weaken or break if not used correctly.	85-98%
Polyurethane Condoms	Made from plastic material, this type of condom is an alternative for people who are allergic to latex.	Effective barrier against STIs and pregnancy, can be used with oil-based lubricants, odorless and transparent.	More expensive than latex condoms, less stretchy and may not fit well for some people.	79-95%
Polyisoprene Condoms	Made from a synthetic material that has similar properties to latex but is hypoallergenic.	Effective barrier against STIs and pregnancy, suitable for people with latex allergies, soft and comfortable.	More expensive than latex condoms, not as widely available.	95-98%
Lambskin Condoms	Made from sheep intestine, this type of condom is a natural and non-latex alternative.	Provides natural feel and sensation, suitable for people with latex allergies.	Not effective against STIs, expensive, not as widely available.	79-95%

Note: The efficacy rate is the percentage of pregnancies prevented with consistent and correct use. Efficacy rates may differ according to where efficacy data is pulled from.

While condoms are highly effective in preventing pregnancy and STIs, some individuals may prefer alternative methods of contraception. One such method is the withdrawal technique, which involves withdrawing the penis from the vagina before ejaculation occurs. In the following sections, we will delve deeper into this method, discussing its benefits, potential drawbacks, and guidelines for correct usage.

Withdrawal Method

The withdrawal method, also known as the pull-out method or coitus interruptus, is a form of contraception where the male partner withdraws his penis from the vagina before ejaculation, thus preventing sperm from entering the uterus. It’s a popular method of birth control due to its simplicity and affordability.

One of the main advantages of using the withdrawal method is that it doesn’t require any special equipment or medication, and it’s completely free. Additionally, some couples find the withdrawal method to be more intimate, as it relies on communication and trust between partners.

However, the withdrawal method has several possible drawbacks or risks. Firstly, it can be difficult for some men to time their withdrawal accurately, and even a tiny amount of semen can lead to pregnancy. Secondly, the withdrawal method offers no protection against sexually transmitted infections (STIs), so it’s essential to use condoms or other barrier methods in conjunction with withdrawal to reduce the risk of STI transmission.

To use the withdrawal method correctly, the male partner should withdraw his penis from the vagina before ejaculation, making sure to avoid any contact between the penis and the vagina, labia, or anus. It’s also essential for the male partner to urinate before sexual activity, as this can help to flush out any leftover semen in the urethra. Finally, it’s recommended to combine the withdrawal method with other forms of contraception, such as condoms or fertility awareness methods, for optimal effectiveness.

Method	Pros	Cons	Efficacy Rate
Withdrawal Method	Free and widely available No hormonal side effects Can be used as a backup method	High failure rate Requires trust and communication with partner Does not protect against STIs	Typical use: 78% Perfect use: 96%

Note: The typical use efficacy rate reflects the effectiveness of the method when it is used in real-world situations, taking into account factors such as incorrect use, inconsistent use, and other user-related factors. The perfect use efficacy rate reflects the effectiveness of the method when it is used ideally, as intended. Efficacy rates may differ according to where efficacy data is pulled from.

There have been studies on the efficacy rates of the withdrawal method. However, it is essential to note that the method’s effectiveness can vary depending on several factors, including the experience and consistency of the individuals using it. According to the Office on Women’s Health (OWH), the typical use failure rate for withdrawal is 22%, meaning that out of 100 women using the method for a year, 22 will become pregnant. However, with perfect use (correct and consistent use every time), the failure rate drops to 4% according to the World Health Organization (WHO). It’s important to remember that no contraception method can provide a 100% protection guarantee. By utilizing a variety of techniques, effectiveness can be improved even further.

While the withdrawal method can be a quick and convenient form of contraception, it may not be the best choice for everyone. For those who want to better understand their fertility and have more control over their reproductive health, fertility awareness methods may be a better option. The following section will explore the different fertility awareness methods available and their unique advantages and disadvantages.

Fertility Awareness Method

Fertility Awareness Method (FAM) is a type of natural family planning that involves tracking your menstrual cycle to determine when you are most and least fertile. This method is based on the fact that a woman’s fertility is not constant but varies throughout her cycle. By closely monitoring changes in cervical fluid (aka cervical mucus), basal body temperature, and other similar signs, you can pinpoint your most fertile days and choose to either abstain from sexual activity or make use of a barrier method during this period.

Types of Fertility Awareness Methods

Fertility Awareness Methods (FAM) encompass a variety of techniques used to monitor reproductive health and plan or prevent pregnancy. While many methods offer valuable approaches, my focus is on the Symptothermal Method, which I teach.

The Symptothermal Method combines the observation of basal body temperature and cervical fluid to accurately identify the fertile window. Each morning, before any activity, you measure your basal body temperature; a rise in temperature typically indicates ovulation. Concurrently, you monitor changes in cervical fluid, which reflect hormonal fluctuations and fertility levels. By understanding these two key indicators, you can effectively determine your most fertile days.

This method offers a comprehensive view of your menstrual cycle, making it a powerful tool for those seeking to achieve or avoid pregnancy through natural means. While other FAM techniques provide insights based on cycle history or single indicators, the Symptothermal Method’s dual approach allows for greater precision and personalization in managing fertility.

Advantages of Using the Fertility Awareness

One of the main advantages of FAM is that it is hormone-free and non-invasive. It can also be used to achieve pregnancy, as couples can have sex during the fertile window to increase their chances of conception. Additionally, some women find that tracking their cycle helps them feel more connected to their bodies and more in control of their reproductive health.

Possible Drawbacks or Risks 

One of the main drawbacks of FAM is that it requires a high level of commitment and diligence in tracking your cycle and using a backup method of contraception during fertile days. As with every form of contraceptive, it becomes less effective if not used correctly or consistently.

How to Use the Fertility Awareness Method

To use FAM correctly, learning how to track your cycle and interpret the signs is essential. It would be best to work with a healthcare provider qualified in FAM or certified fertility awareness educator (FAE) to learn the method and ensure you use it correctly. Additionally, using a backup method of contraception during fertile days is essential to prevent unintended pregnancy.

Some FAM Type	Description	Pros	Cons	Efficacy Rate
Symptothermal	Combines observations of cervical mucus, basal body temperature (BBT), and other biological signs such as changes in the cervix or secondary fertility signs, to identify fertile and infertile phases of a woman’s menstrual cycle.	Provides detailed insights into ovulation patterns. Confirms ovulation with advance notice. No special tools or devices needed, lowering costs. Suitable for women with both irregular and regular cycles.	Requires strict routine adherence. Susceptible to disruptions from medications, illness, and hormonal changes. Needs proper training and education for effective use.	99.6% with perfect use 98.4% with typical use
Billings Cervical Mucus Method	Also known as the Billings Ovulation Method, involves tracking changes in cervical mucus to assess fertility. Users observe the color, consistency, and sensation of their cervical mucus daily to determine their fertile and infertile phases.	No medications or devices required. No ongoing costs for tests or devices. Enhances understanding of menstrual cycle and fertility signs. Effective for both irregular and regular cycles.	Requires consistency and meticulous attention to detail. Accuracy depends on correct observation and interpretation of cervical mucus. Does not protect against sexually transmitted infections. Proficiency may take several cycles to achieve.	98.9% with perfect use 89.5% with typical use
TwoDay	Involves tracking the presence or absence of cervical mucus. Users check for cervical mucus at least twice a day and consider themselves fertile if they notice mucus today or noticed it on the previous day.	Straightforward daily cervical mucus check. No special tools or devices needed, reducing costs. Immediate use with no extensive training required. Suitable for women with regular or irregular cycles.	Requires checking mucus at least twice daily, which can be inconvenient or forgotten. Less effective than multi-indicator methods, increasing the risk of misidentifying fertile days. Does not protect against sexually transmitted infections. Effectiveness relies on accurate identification of cervical mucus.	96% with perfect use 86% with typical use
Marquette	Combines fertility awareness with a fertility monitor that measures hormone levels in urine.	High accuracy in predicting fertile days using a hormone monitor. Reduces user interpretation errors by providing objective fertility data. Simplifies the process with technology, easier than methods requiring subjective observations. Suitable for women with regular or irregular cycles; adaptable for various family planning goals.	Requires initial purchase of a fertility monitor and ongoing costs for test sticks. Dependent on the availability and functioning of the ClearBlue Fertility Monitor. Does not offer protection against sexually transmitted infections. Maintenance and battery management of the device are necessary, which can be cumbersome.	98-99% with perfect use 86-93% with typical use

Note: Efficacy rates are based on typical use unless otherwise noted. Perfect use refers to using a contraceptive method consistently and correctly every time during sexual activity. In contrast, typical use considers human error, such as forgetting or misusing the technique. It is important to note that perfect use efficacy rates are often higher than usual. Efficacy rates may differ according to where efficacy data is pulled from.

 

Now that we have discussed the Fertility Awareness Method let’s compare and contrast it with the other two methods – condoms and withdrawal – and see how they stack up against each other in terms of efficacy, STI prevention, and effects on fertility.

Comparing & Contrasting 

When it comes to contraception, there are many options available, including condoms, withdrawal, and fertility awareness methods. Each method has its benefits and drawbacks to consider.

Condoms, for example, are a popular choice due to their effectiveness in preventing both pregnancy and sexually transmitted infections (STIs). They are easy to use and widely available, making them a convenient option for many people. Although condoms are a reliable form of contraception, they may not always be 100% effective due to the likelihood of breakage or slippage during sexual activity. Additionally, latex is the most frequently used material for condoms, but it can cause allergic reactions in some individuals.

Withdrawal, on the other hand, is a method that involves the male partner pulling out before ejaculation. While this method is free and requires no additional tools or products, it cannot be easy to use correctly and consistently. Pre-ejaculate fluid can also contain sperm, increasing the risk of pregnancy. Additionally, this method does not protect against STIs.

Fertility awareness methods involve tracking a person’s menstrual cycle to identify their fertile window and avoiding sex or using other forms of contraception during that time. While these methods can be highly effective when used correctly, they require careful tracking. They may not be suitable for people with irregular periods or who are not comfortable with monitoring their fertility. Additionally, these methods do not protect against STIs.

It’s essential to consider the impact of each method on fertility and STI transmission as well. Condoms and withdrawal do not affect fertility, while some fertility awareness methods can help people better understand and track their fertility. Proper and consistent use of any of the three methods can effectively hinder the transmission of STIs.

Ultimately, the best method of contraception will depend on each individual’s unique circumstances and preferences. To make a well-informed decision, it is critical to discuss and consider all available options with a healthcare provider.

Method	Pros	Cons	Ease of Use	STI Protection	Effect on Fertility	Efficacy
Condoms	Highly effective at preventing STIs and HIV	Can reduce sensation during sex	Requires use during every sexual encounter	Yes	None	98% with perfect use 82% with typical us
Withdrawal	Free	High failure rate	Requires significant self-control and practice	No	None	96% with perfect use 78% with typical us
Fertility Awareness (Sympto-thermal)	Hormone-free	High user reliance and motivation required	Requires daily monitoring of fertility signs	No	May support in optimizing chances of TTC	99.6% with perfect use 98.4% with typical us

Note: Efficacy rates are based on typical use unless otherwise noted. Perfect use refers to using the method exactly as directed every time. Efficacy rates may differ according to where efficacy data is pulled from.

Choosing the Right Method for You

It is crucial to select a contraception method that aligns with your requirements and choices. There are several factors to consider when deciding on a contraceptive method, including your lifestyle, medical history, and sexual behavior.

First, think about the effectiveness of each method. Condoms, withdrawal, and fertility awareness methods all have different efficacy rates. It’s important to understand these rates and choose a method that aligns with your desired level of protection.

Another factor to consider is ease of use. Condoms are generally straightforward to use, while fertility awareness methods require more education and practice. Withdrawal method requires self-control and can be challenging to master.

It’s also essential to think about STI prevention. Condoms are the only method that protects against most sexually transmitted infections, while withdrawal and fertility awareness do not offer any protection against STIs.

Your healthcare provider, fertility awareness educator, or sexual-reproductive health specialist can help you choose the proper method for you. They can guide you on using the technique correctly and discuss any potential side effects or risks.

It is important that you use contraception consistently and correctly, no matter which method you choose. Using a technique incorrectly or inconsistently can significantly reduce its efficacy, leading to unintended pregnancy or increased risk of STIs.

Here’s a checklist to help you choose the best contraceptive method for yourself:

1. Consider your personal preferences: Think about what kind of contraception you feel most comfortable using. Are you comfortable with hormonal methods, or do you prefer non-hormonal options? Do you prefer a technique that requires daily use, or would you like a long-acting option?
2. Evaluate your medical history: Certain medical conditions, such as blood clotting disorders or liver disease, can limit your options. The most reliable way to determine which methods are safe for you is through consulting with your healthcare provider.
3. Consider your lifestyle: Certain methods may be more suitable depending on your lifestyle. For example, if you have multiple sexual partners, using condoms may be an excellent option to protect against STIs.
4. Consult with a professional: A contraception care expert or a sexual-reproductive health educator can offer you support in comprehending the advantages and disadvantages of each strategy, and can aid you in picking the most efficient technique that suits your requirements.
5. Ensure consistent and correct use: No matter which method you choose, it’s essential to use it consistently and correctly to ensure maximum effectiveness.

 

By considering these factors and consulting with a healthcare provider, sexual reproductive health specialist, or fertility awareness educator, you can choose the best contraceptive method for your needs and ensure reproductive health.

Key Points & Conclusion

Let’s review the key points from this blog on some of your contraceptive care options, specifically condoms, withdrawal, and fertility awareness based methods.

Key Points

• Contraception is an integral part of family planning and reproductive health.
• The three methods discussed in this post are condoms, withdrawal, and fertility awareness.
• Barrier methods such as condoms can prevent both STIs and pregnancy, but their effectiveness depends on consistent and accurate usage.
• Withdrawal involves removing the penis before ejaculation, but it can be challenging to use correctly and may not protect against STIs.
• Fertility awareness involves tracking ovulation and abstaining from sex during fertile periods, but it requires commitment and may not be effective for all people.
• When choosing a method, it’s essential to consider factors such as effectiveness, ease of use, and STI protection.
• Consulting with a healthcare provider or sexual-reproductive health specialist can help you choose the proper method for you.
• Using contraception consistently and correctly is crucial to its effectiveness in preventing unintended pregnancy and protecting against STIs.

 

Conclusion

In summary, condoms, withdrawal methods, and fertility awareness methods are all effective forms of contraception with their unique advantages and drawbacks. Condoms are easy to use, protect against STIs, and have high efficacy rates, but may reduce sensitivity and may not always be available. The withdrawal method is a convenient and accessible option, but it requires self-control and may not protect against STIs. The fertility awareness method allows for hormone-free contraception and body literacy but requires commitment and does not protect against STIs.

When selecting a method, it is important to consider elements such as individual choice, way of life, and health circumstances. It is important to keep these in mind before making a decision. Consultation with a healthcare provider, fertility awareness educator, or sexual-reproductive health specialist can help guide the decision-making process and ensure the proper use and effectiveness of the chosen method.

Ultimately, using contraception consistently and correctly is critical to effective contraceptive care and maintaining reproductive health. By understanding the pros and cons of each method and choosing the right one for you, you can take charge of your reproductive future and prevent unintended pregnancies and STIs.

About Majida

Sources

1. Berglund Scherwitzl, E., Gemzell Danielsson, K., Sellberg, J. A., & Scherwitzl, R. (2016). Fertility awareness-based mobile application for contraception. The European Journal of Contraception & Reproductive Health Care, 21(3), 234–241. https://doi.org/10.3109/13625187.2016.1154143 
2. Dickson, R. (2022, May 30). Effectiveness of fertility awareness-based methods: What are the facts?. FACTS About Fertility. https://www.factsaboutfertility.org/effectiveness-of-fertility-awareness-based-methods-what-are-the-facts/
3. Duane, M., Stanford, J. B., Porucznik, C. A., & Vigil, P. (2022). Fertility awareness-based methods for women’s health and Family Planning. Frontiers in Medicine, 9. https://doi.org/10.3389/fmed.2022.858977 
4. Hendrickson-Jack, L. (2019). The fifth vital sign: Master your cycles & optimize your fertility. Fertility Friday Publishing Inc.
5. Frank-Herrmann, P., Heil, J., Gnoth, C., Toledo, E., Baur, S., Pyper, C., Jenetzky, E., Strowitzki, T., & Freundl, G. (2007). The effectiveness of a fertility awareness based method to avoid pregnancy in relation to a couple’s sexual behaviour during the fertile time: A prospective longitudinal study. Human Reproduction, 22(5), 1310–1319. https://doi.org/10.1093/humrep/dem003
6. Howard, S. A., & Benhabbour, S. R. (2023). Non-hormonal contraception. Journal of Clinical Medicine, 12(14), 4791. https://doi.org/10.3390/jcm12144791
7. MediLexicon International. (2024). Pregnancy and the pull-out method: What to know. Medical News Today. https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/can-you-get-pregnant-with-the-pull-out-method#:~:text=According%20to%20the%20Office%20on,the%20common%20use%20of%20condoms. 
8. Peragallo Urrutia, R., Polis, C. B., Jensen, E. T., Greene, M. E., Kennedy, E., & Stanford, J. B. (2018). Effectiveness of fertility awareness–based methods for pregnancy prevention. Obstetrics & Gynecology, 132(3), 591–604. https://doi.org/10.1097/aog.0000000000002784 
9. Reece, M., Herbenick, D., Schick, V., Sanders, S. A., Dodge, B., & Fortenberry, J. D. (2010). Condom use rates in a national probability sample of males and females ages 14 to 94 in the United States. The Journal of Sexual Medicine, 7(Supplement 5), 266–276. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1743-6109.2010.02017.x 
10. Siegel, D. R., Sheeder, J., & Polotsky, A. J. (2021). Racial and ethnic disparities in fertility awareness among reproductive-aged women. Women’s Health Reports, 2(1), 347–354. https://doi.org/10.1089/whr.2021.0034 
11. Singer, K. (2004). The Garden of Fertility: A Guide to charting your fertility signals to prevent or achieve pregnancy – naturally – and to gauge your reproductive health. Avery. 
12. Stachowska, A., Kicińska, A. M., & Wierzba, T. H. (2022). The history of Fertility Awareness Methods. Kwartalnik Naukowy Fides et Ratio, 3(51), 9–19. https://doi.org/10.34766/fetr.v3i51.1093 
13. United Nations. (2019). Contraceptive use by method 2019. United Nations. https://www.un.org/development/desa/pd/sites/www.un.org.development.desa.pd/files/files/documents/2020/Jan/un_2019_contraceptiveusebymethod_databooklet.pdf 
14. Weschler, T. (2016). Taking charge of your fertility the definitive guide to Natural Birth Control, pregnancy achievement, and Reproductive Health. Vermilion.
15. World Health Organization. (2024, February 12). Condoms. World Health Organization. https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/condoms

 

Disclaimer:

The information provided on this blog is for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. The content on this blog is not meant to replace professional medical advice or to be used to prevent, diagnose, or treat any disease or illness. Reliance on any information provided by this blog is solely at your own risk.